Friday, January 15, 2016

The Swans of Fifth Avenue by Melanie Benjamin

The Swans of Fifth Avenue by Melanie Benjamin
Published January 2016 by Delacourt Press
Source: my copy courtesy of the publisher by way of Netgalley

Publisher's Summary:
Of all the glamorous stars of New York high society, none blazes brighter than Babe Paley. Her flawless face regularly graces the pages of Vogue, and she is celebrated and adored for her ineffable style and exquisite taste, especially among her friends—the alluring socialite Swans Slim Keith, C. Z. Guest, Gloria Guinness, and Pamela Churchill. By all appearances, Babe has it all: money, beauty, glamour, jewels, influential friends, a prestigious husband, and gorgeous homes. But beneath this elegantly composed exterior dwells a passionate woman—a woman desperately longing for true love and connection.

Enter Truman Capote. This diminutive golden-haired genius with a larger-than-life personality explodes onto the scene, setting Babe and her circle of Swans aflutter. Through Babe, Truman gains an unlikely entrĂ©e into the enviable lives of Manhattan’s elite, along with unparalleled access to the scandal and gossip of Babe’s powerful circle. Sure of the loyalty of the man she calls “True Heart,” Babe never imagines the destruction Truman will leave in his wake. But once a storyteller, always a storyteller—even when the stories aren’t his to tell.

Truman’s fame is at its peak when such notable celebrities as Frank and Mia Sinatra, Lauren Bacall, and Rose Kennedy converge on his glittering Black and White Ball. But all too soon, he’ll ignite a literary scandal whose repercussions echo through the years.

My Thoughts:

  • The perfect juxtaposition to my first book of the year (Caitlin Moran's How To Be A Woman), in The Swans of Fifth Avenue Melanie Benjamin tells the tale of a group of 1950's socialites enjoying the world just before feminism really took off. Even with all of the money, the jewels, the fashion, the staff, these women were entirely reliant on rich men and their worth seemed to be completely based on their look. For a brief period, Babe worked as a fashion editor at Vogue. It helped her refine her style but was also the last time she was any thing other than William Paley's wife, style icon, queen of the swans. Some of the other swans also had brief careers but, ultimately, they all spent the rest of their lives working at marrying well.



  • I've learned through listening to Melanie Benjamin talk about her writing, reading her books, and doing some follow up research, Benjamin does a bang up job of researching her books. This book is no exception. As it's about a more current subject than her others, it's easier to do a little digging and check the facts. There may be some places where Benjamin has played with the facts but certainly nothing major as far as I can see. Which, for me, makes the fiction piece all the more impressive when it's been worked entirely into the known.
  • Benjamin may have painted Babe Paley as a more sympathetic character than I've seen her portrayed elsewhere, but she also doesn't shy away from showing Paley's real warts. She was, for example, a terrible mother and Benjamin's Babe doesn't seem to feel much guilt about it.
  • Conversely, Benjamin manages to make Capote not an altogether unlikable character (at least early on) by letting readers see into his childhood and the difficulties he faced as a gay man in the 1950's.               
  • The book may be about all of Capote's swans but it is, at it's heart, the story of the love that Babe and Truman shared, both of them desperately seeking someone who would love them for who they really are. Babe let Truman see the woman, literally, behind the mask, something even her husband was not allowed to see. 
  • In the end, Truman Capote became a caricature of his flamboyant younger self, someone who flaws seemed to have become ever more exaggerated. Benjamin paints a picture of a man so desperate for success and fame that he betrays the confidence of those he claimed to love but so lost that he doesn't truly understand why.
  • Babe, on the other hand, faced death as exactly the woman she spent her life creating. Dying of cancer, she planned her entire funeral, right down to the catered food, the wine, and the flowers.                                                              In Benjamin's hands, Babe Paley, a woman who had it all, became someone I pitied as she laid dying, surrounded by children who there out of obligation and estranged from the only man she'd truly loved.
  • Bottom line: I thoroughly enjoyed this The Swans of Fifth Avenue!

10 comments:

  1. After reading several years ago about the relationship between Harper Lee and Truman Capote, I did not find him very likeable. I think this book would be quite interesting. Thanks for adding to the story by giving your thoughts here.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. He was not a likable man - apparently entertaining enough that people were willing to accept that about him.

      Delete
  2. This sounds amazing. Like Kay I've never found Capote particularly likable but I am interested in learning more about the Swans - particularly Babe Paley.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The swans were interesting - as written by Benjamin, they were very much like a group of high-school girlfriends but with much more at stake.

      Delete
  3. This isn't a book I see myself reading, admittedly, but I am intrigued. I only know Capote as the media has portrayed him. It sounds like Benjamin did a wonderful job researching and writing this book.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Of course, Benjamin didn't know him so her portrayal is based on research but from what she was able to glean about him, I'd say the media was pretty fair.

      Delete
  4. Wow. This is a part of history I wouldn't have thought much about. Impressive fact-checking too!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. One of the things that was interesting was reading about the swans as they aged and were no longer "the" people to be with.

      Delete
  5. I don't think I have ever Googled a subject so much while reading a book as I did with this one. I wanted to learn so much more about Capote's swans. I had my iPad or phone next to me at all times so that I could refer to the Internet whenever something made me curious. I love that Benjamin made me so interested in her subjects!

    That being said, I loved this first half of this one, but by the time Capote started hitting the self-medication stage of his life, I lost interest. It definitely wasn't Benjamin's fault; her writing and her research are impeccable. I just grew tired of Capote's antics and Paley's self-lamentations.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It did tend to get stuck at places on how each of them viewed their relationship and their feelings.

      Delete