This week's fairy tale love story is "Rapunzel." The story of "Rapunzel" as we are most familiar with it is the Grimm Brothers version.Here's something interesting I found while researching the tale of Rapunzel, however, a side by side comparison of the Grimm Brothers' take on the Rapunzel. It appears that even the good brothers had multiple versions of the tale!
The Brothers Grimm was adapted their story from "Persinette" which was written in 1698 by Charlotte-Rose de Caumont de La Force (the dauphine of Louis XIV of France). Another influence on the familiar tale was "Petrosinella" told by Giambattista Basile (yeah, him again). But the origins of "Rapunzel" are much older. A 10th-century Persian fairy tale, Rudaba, appears to be the original twist on the tale of a woman letting down her hair for access to her tower prison.
Once again we have a fairy tale that opens with a couple wishing for a child. In their home, there is a small window in back that overlooks a walled garden owned by a witch. One day as the woman is looking out at the garden she sees some rampion radish (rapunzel) and is overcome with a desire to have some. Eventually her craving becomes so great that she tells her husband she will die without eating some. So two nights in a row he risks the witch to get his wife some rampion. But on the second night the witch catches him. When he tells her why he is there, she allows him to take all he wants in order to keep his wife alive but the cost will be his unborn child (although the version I read doesn't say so, it's clear that the woman's insatiable craving is a result of pregnancy). The man agrees and when the child is born, the witch takes her and locks her in a tower where there are no stairs or doorways. To gain access the witch calls to the child, Rapunzel, to lower her hair which the witch scales to reach the top. One day a prince riding nearby hears Rapunzel singing and is enchanted. But he can't figure out how to get to her until he happens to see the witch, one night, calling out to Rapunzel. The next day he does the same thing. Of course, Rapunzel, who until then had never seen a man, falls in love with him and allows the prince to visit her daily and they devise a plan to help Rapunzel escape. But just before they are able to effect the escape, Rapunzel lets slip to the witch that the prince has been visiting. The witch chops off Rapunzel's hair then takes her to a remote desert. When the prince returns, the witch lowers the Rapunzel's hair. When the prince reaches the summit, the witch tells him he will never see Rapunzel again but before she can kill him, the prince leaps from the tower. He survives but has landed in thorns which blind him, fulfilling the witch's prophecy. Despondent, the prince wanders then land until one day he stumbles upon Rapunzel. Recognizing him, she cries because of what has happened to him. Miraculously, her tears heal his eyes and the couple...and their child...return to the prince's kingdom.
After we saw the Disney movie I read this story to my daughter.
ReplyDeleteActually it sounds kind of like Jane Eyre, when you think about it!
ReplyDeleteOnce again, you have surprised me with all the depth and variation that I never knew this old fairy tale had! I have always loved this story, but hearing this other version was quite eye-opening for me. These stories are so not meant for children!
ReplyDeleteThat's the version in the Broadway play "Into the Woods." I always loved that version the best. Awesome musical, too.
ReplyDeleteI always felt sorry for Rapunzel--though I guess all those gals had it rough at one point or another! ;)
ReplyDeleteI literally said "Wow!" when I read the bit about the tale going all the way back to the 10th century. It's amazing how things stories continue to evolve over time for centuries and centuries.
I love this story!!
ReplyDeleteI like the fact that the Disney movie gives a reason for the witch to take and keep Rapunzel. I read the Grimm story when I was young (eek!), and never could understand why the witch wanted the girl. Seemed like a lot of work to me...
ReplyDeleteLove this review of fairy tales!
Rapunzel is one of my favorites b/c I had long hair as a child, and thought some day I would be rescued from the tower too! LOL!
ReplyDeleteToo funny, Brenda! Isn't it funny the way kids' minds work? I mean, to be rescued that way would mean you'd have had to be imprisoned in a tower to begin with and you could hardly have wanted that to happen!
ReplyDeleteLove your fairy-story posts.
ReplyDeleteAlthough somehow I never remember them on Friday.
Love Rapunzel! In fact, many of the modern versions of fairy tales of this one are my favorite too!
ReplyDelete